Dr. Tornike Shurgulaia is a distinguished figure in the realm of global security and intelligence, with a career that spans over a decade as a professor, author, researcher, public speaker, trainer, expert, and consultant. His extensive experience encompasses work with governmental and non-governmental organizations, political parties, and the academic sector. Dr. Shurgulaia's expertise is deeply rooted in Global Security, Intelligence and counterintelligence, U.S. foreign policy, and international relations (IR).
The recent outbreak of regional conflicts across the globe has brought both traditional and non-traditional security issues back into the spotlight. That is why the Centre invited Dr. Tornike Shurgulaia, an expert in the field of security, to share his views on recent global and regional developments.
SPCIS: In light of recent global developments, how do you see the major trends in global security evolving over the next decade? What role do you envision for regional organizations in maintaining stability?
Dr. Tornike Shurgulaia: I can provide some insights based on current trends and projections. Over the next decade, major trends in global security are likely to be influenced by factors such as technological advancements, climate change, geopolitical tensions, and non-state actors. Cybersecurity threats are expected to continue to rise, while issues like resource scarcity and political instability could lead to conflicts.
Regional organizations are expected to play a crucial role in maintaining stability. They can facilitate dialogue, cooperation, and conflict resolution among member states. By fostering trust and building mechanisms for joint action, regional organizations can help prevent and resolve disputes, promote peacekeeping efforts, and address shared security challenges effectively.
It's important for these organizations to adapt to evolving security threats and dynamics, strengthen their institutional capacity, and collaborate with other international bodies to address global security challenges comprehensively. By promoting security cooperation and enhancing regional integration, these organizations can contribute significantly to enhancing stability and security in the coming years.
SPCIS: Given the diverse political and economic landscapes in Eastern Europe, what strategies do you believe could enhance regional cooperation and collective security without compromising national interests?
Dr. Tornike Shurgulaia: Enhancing regional cooperation and collective security in Eastern Europe while respecting national interests requires a delicate balance and a multifaceted approach. Here are some strategies that could be considered:
- Multilateral Dialogue and Diplomacy: Facilitate regular dialogues and diplomatic engagements among Eastern European countries through regional organizations like the EU, NATO, or the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE). Encouraging open communication and cooperation can help build trust and foster mutual understanding.
- Mutual Security Assurances: Provide mutual security assurances and commitments among Eastern European countries to address common security challenges and threats. Establishing mechanisms for collective defense and response can enhance regional stability without undermining national sovereignty.
- Economic Integration: Promote economic integration and cooperation through initiatives like trade agreements, infrastructure projects, and investment partnerships. By improving economic ties, Eastern European countries can foster interdependence and reduce the likelihood of conflicts arising from economic disparities.
- Capacity-Building and Security Sector Reform: Invest in capacity-building programs and security sector reform to enhance the capabilities of Eastern European states in addressing security threats effectively. Training programs, joint exercises, and information sharing can strengthen regional security cooperation.
- Conflict Prevention and Crisis Management: Develop early warning mechanisms, mediation processes, and crisis management protocols to prevent conflicts and manage crises effectively. Establishing a framework for conflict prevention can help mitigate risks and maintain peace in Eastern Europe.
- Civil Society Engagement: Engage civil society organizations, non-governmental entities, and local communities in promoting dialogue, reconciliation, and peacebuilding efforts. Civil society plays a critical role in fostering grassroots initiatives and building sustainable peace in the region.
By implementing these strategies, Eastern European countries can enhance regional cooperation and collective security while safeguarding their national interests. Collaboration, trust-building, and a shared commitment to peace and stability are key principles that can guide efforts towards a more secure and prosperous Eastern Europe.
SPCIS: The South Caucasus has been a hotspot for various security (traditional and nontraditional) challenges. What are the key issues you identify in this region, and how can regional and international actors effectively address these challenges?
Dr. Tornike Shurgulaia: In the South Caucasus region, several key security challenges persist, encompassing both traditional and non-traditional threats, Russia and it’s Hybrid war is most high level threat for region. Some of the major issues include unresolved territorial conflicts (such as the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan), ethnic tensions, militarization, border disputes, terrorism, organized crime, and energy security concerns. Addressing these challenges effectively requires coordinated efforts from both regional and international actors. Here are some potential strategies:
- Conflict Resolution and Diplomacy: Regional and international actors can play a crucial role in facilitating dialogue, negotiations, and peace processes to resolve existing territorial conflicts and mitigate ethnic tensions. Engaging in diplomatic efforts, mediation, and confidence-building measures can help build trust and foster peaceful resolutions.
- Security Sector Reform: Implementing security sector reform programs to enhance institutional capacity, transparency, and accountability in the South Caucasus states can help address issues related to militarization, border security, and counterterrorism efforts. Strengthening governance structures within the security sector is essential for promoting stability.
- Cross-Border Cooperation: Encouraging regional cooperation on security issues, including joint military exercises, intelligence-sharing mechanisms, and border management initiatives, can enhance security collaboration among South Caucasus countries. Building strong regional ties can help prevent transnational threats from proliferating.
- Economic Integration: Promoting economic integration and connectivity projects within the South Caucasus region, such as infrastructure development, trade agreements, and energy cooperation, can foster interdependence and stability. Enhancing economic ties can create common interests that support peace-building efforts.
- Countering Non-Traditional Threats: Collaborating on countering non-traditional threats like terrorism, organized crime, cyberattacks, and extremism through intelligence-sharing, capacity-building programs, and joint law enforcement initiatives is crucial. Addressing these emerging challenges proactively can enhance overall security in the region.
- Engagement with Civil Society: Involving civil society organizations, local communities, and grassroots initiatives in promoting dialogue, reconciliation, and conflict prevention can contribute to sustainable peace-building efforts in the South Caucasus. Civil society engagement can facilitate bottom-up approaches to addressing security challenges.
By implementing a comprehensive approach that combines diplomatic efforts, security sector reform, economic cooperation, and civil society engagement, both regional and international actors can work together to address the multifaceted security challenges in the South Caucasus region effectively and contribute to long-term stability and peace.
SPCIS: How do external powers influence security dynamics in Eastern Europe and the South Caucasus, and what measures can be taken to balance these influences to promote regional stability?
Dr. Tornike Shurgulaia: The security landscape in Eastern Europe and the South Caucasus is heavily influenced by external powers. Here's a breakdown of their roles:
1. Russia:
- Dominant player with historical ties and military presence.
- Seeks to maintain its sphere of influence and counter Western expansion (NATO, EU).
- Supports breakaway regions and uses frozen conflicts as leverage.
- Occupation and Military oppression is Russian toll to create chaos.
2. The West (EU, NATO):
- Promotes democracy, human rights, and Euro-Atlantic integration.
- Offers security guarantees through NATO membership but faces limitations due to Russian opposition.
- Provides economic and political assistance.
3. Other regional players:
- Turkey and Iran also are influential powers, with complex relationships with both Russia and the West.
These competing interests create a complex security dynamic:
- Increased militarization: Tensions lead to arms buildups and military exercises, raising the risk of accidental escalation.
- Frozen conflicts: External powers can exacerbate unresolved territorial disputes, hindering regional cooperation.
- Instability and democratic backsliding: External competition can weaken institutions and fuel internal divisions exclamation.
Finding a balance between these external forces is crucial for regional stability. Here are some potential measures:
1. Dialogue and Confidence-Building Measures:
- Fostering direct communication between Russia and the West can reduce miscalculations and build trust.
- Military transparency measures and arms control agreements could ease tensions.
2. Strengthening Regional Institutions:
- Organizations like the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) can provide platforms for dialogue and conflict resolution.
- Encouraging regional cooperation on economic and security issues can build trust and interdependence.
3. Promoting Democratic Values and Institutions:
- Strengthening democratic institutions in Eastern Europe and the South Caucasus makes them less susceptible to external manipulation.
- The West can support civil society and independent media.
4. Targeted Sanctions and Diplomacy:
- The international community can use targeted sanctions and diplomatic pressure to deter aggressive actions and promote peaceful solutions.
Challenges: Finding common ground between Russia and the West can be difficult. Internal political divisions within the region can hinder cooperation. Long-standing historical grievances and unresolved conflicts can complicate efforts at reconciliation.
SPCIS: Looking ahead, what changes or reforms would you suggest for existing regional security frameworks in Eastern Europe and the South Caucasus to better address both traditional and non-traditional security challenges?
Dr. Tornike Shurgulaia: Here are some potential changes and reforms for existing regional security frameworks in Eastern Europe and the South Caucasus:
Addressing Traditional Security Challenges:
1. Enhanced Conflict Resolution Mechanisms:
- Streamline existing frameworks within the OSCE or create a dedicated regional body for conflict resolution.
- This body could provide neutral mediation, fact-finding missions, and deploy international observers in sensitive areas.
2. Cybersecurity Cooperation:
- Develop regional cyber defense strategies and information sharing protocols.
- Establish joint training exercises to improve collective response to cyberattacks.
3. Joint Military Exercises:
- Move beyond traditional West vs. East exercises.
- Design exercises focused on shared threats like counter-terrorism, disaster relief, and peacekeeping. This fosters interoperability and trust.
Addressing Non-Traditional Security Challenges:
1. Environmental Security:
- Integrate environmental concerns into regional security discussions.
- Address issues like water scarcity, transboundary pollution, and the impact of climate change on regional stability.
2. Energy Security:
- Promote diversification of energy sources and infrastructure to reduce dependence on single suppliers.
- Develop a regional energy market to enhance security and economic cooperation.
3. Organized Crime and Corruption:
- Establish joint task forces and information sharing networks to combat transnational criminal activities.
- Promote transparency and accountability within regional institutions to reduce corruption.
Strengthening Regional Frameworks:
1.Inclusive Membership:
- Encourage broader participation from regional players beyond just NATO and CSTO (Collective Security Treaty Organization).
- This fosters a sense of regional ownership and strengthens the legitimacy of the framework.
2.Focus on Capacity Building:
- Provide training and resources to strengthen the capabilities of regional institutions for conflict prevention, crisis management, and post-conflict reconstruction.
3.Promote Civil Society Engagement:
- Include civil society organizations in regional security discussions.
- Their involvement can bring valuable perspectives and contribute to conflict prevention efforts.
Challenges:
1. Political Will:
- Member states need to be willing to cede some autonomy and prioritize regional stability over national interests.
- Building trust and overcoming historical grievances will be crucial.
2. Financial Resources:
- Implementing these reforms will require sustained financial commitment from member states and international donors.
By adapting to address both traditional and non-traditional security challenges, regional security frameworks in Eastern Europe and the South Caucasus can play a more effective role in promoting long-term stability and prosperity in the region.
Comments